Edinburgh South U20s 4-3 Penicuik Athletic U20s
- May 11
Edinburgh Community U20s 0-11 Penicuik Athletic U20s
- May 4
Dunbar United U20s 3-2 Penicuik Athletic U20s
- Apr 13
Penicuik Athletic U20s 9-0 Dalkeith Thistle U20s
- Apr 6
Arniston Rangers U20s 0-15 Penicuik Athletic U20s
- Mar 10
Penicuik Athletic 1-2 Dundonald Bluebell
- Mar 9
Penicuik Athletic U20s 4-2 Hutchison Vale U20s
- Mar 2
Preston Athletic U20s 6-3 Penicuik Athletic U20s
- Feb 17
Sauchie Juniors U20s (5) 2-2 (3) Penicuik Athletic U20s
- Feb 3
Penicuik Athletic U20s 5-3 Whitehill Welfare U20s
- Jan 27
Newtongrange Star U20s 3-6 Penicuik Athletic U20s
- Jan 14
Leith Athletic U20s 2-4 Penicuik Athletic U20s
- Dec 9, 2023
Penicuik Athletic U20s 3-3 Edinburgh South U20s
- Nov 11, 2023
Penicuik Athletic U20s 4-2 Edinburgh Community U20s
- Oct 28, 2023
Dalkeith Thistle U20s 2-5 Penicuik Athletic U20s
- Oct 18, 2023
Penicuik Athletic 3-1 Edinburgh South
- Oct 14, 2023
Penicuik Athletic U20s 6-0 Arniston Rangers U20s
- Sep 30, 2023
Penicuik Athletic U20s 5-6 Preston Athletic U20s
- Sep 16, 2023
Musselburgh Athletic U20s 3-3 Penicuik Athletic U20s
- Sep 9, 2023
Penicuik Athletic U20s 5-0 Tynecastle U20s